
For the developing canon of Pride and Punishment, I introduce A Crappy Movie You Shouldn't Watch But Should Read My Self-Congratulatory Deconstruction Of And This Other Movie That's Actually Worth Adding to Your Netflix Queue, you Spoiled, Isolated, Entertainment Junkie.
Today's screed covers the spectrum from "rugged individualist" subliminal Republican propaganda to foreign anti-authoritarian social commentary on why you don't ever fuck with an honest man's sense of dignity, especially when he's up to bust some merciless samurai shit on you. Somehow I'll fit global conspiracy boogymen in here, because if you can't connect something to your irrational fantasies about reptilian humanoids and Pierre L'Enfant, why talk about it, right?
In The Middle Mind, Curtis White points out that while a very small cadre of academics, social commentators, and political consultants (as well as *cough* eccentric, self-involved idiots on the internet) battle it out with each other over whether America's primary color-code is "blue" or "red," our actual cultural reality is being constructed by a mind-numbing and stupidly bland pop consumerism that soothingly offers us constant, hollow entertainment; while we disinterestedly dismiss any meaningful evaluation of the significance of the many images we absorb through the monolithic media landscape that we're submerged in every day, our subconscious attitudes about life and our society (whatever the fuck that refers to at this point) are profoundly reflected in those images, as they appear in the movies we watch, music we listen to, and products we buy.
Or in other words, no matter what flavor-of-the-month nepotistic power struggle is currently playing itself out behind closed doors in the eye of the pyramid, Americans are busy watching very obnoxious movies and not paying attention to why we like them, or what they might say about us and our values.
In that vein, we come to The Pursuit of Happyness, 2006's terrifying tribute to social darwinism, the beauty of being utterly dependent on disinterested, samsaric institutions for survival, and the old-fashioned American dream of Getting Paid.
Based on the true story of Chris Gardener, the film is equal parts Jacob's Ladder and Jim Cramer; backdropped by vivid depictions of the ruthless reality faced by the millions of people who must cope with America's lack of a meaningful social safety net, it somehow manages to present itself as a modern-day Miracle of Christmas, "Big Bird and Elmo go to Afghanistan."
The movie is a perfect (and completely inadvertently brilliant) depiction of why the income gap between rich and poor in this country is so embarrassingly wide, and why as long as we're knee-deep in disposable income and prozac-laden success myths, we don't need to give a shit about it anyway because it's not our problem.
Offering an extremely fictionalized version of the events that led up to Gardener's journey from broke and homeless single-parenthood to well-compensated corporate serfdom, from sleep-in-the-bathroom to keys-to-the-bathroom, The Pursuit of Happyness might as well be a joint venture between Albert Speer and William Buckley.
The message of the movie is simple: "the only thing keeping poor people from becoming wealthy people is a 'can-do!' attitude of perseverance, the ability to bullshit well with pasty, well-connected overweight WASPs, and a humble reverence for power." Well ... that and the ability to finish a rubix cube in like 10 minutes flat. That helps, apparently.
After losing the family's already second-hand shirt by investing his life savings into obsolete medical technology, budding-entrepreneur Will Smith-as-Gardener finds himself broke, on the streets, and hauling his four-year-old son from shelter to shelter while he pursues what one can only imagine would be the logical next step from that position: making fistfuls of cash in a corporate job, selling stocks for Fortune 500 brokerage Dean Whitter.
Bear in mind that the story is set in the 1980s, no small irony when one considers the hacksaw that the Reagan Administration took to social benefits during that era, and the concurrent ruthless stereotyping of underprivileged single black parents as "welfare queens with welfare Cadillacs" that accompanied the cuts.

Despite (and probably due to) being, in fact, based on a true story, the movie presents itself as a kitsch-y Disney fable; the good guy wins because destiny and the world wants him to, and the only relevant context is Gardener's individual yellow brick road (which you never really believe isn't going to eventually lead to a rainbow).
Images of pain, poverty, and alienation are used to set the scene, not as thematic observations about the world around Smith, which in truth he really never seems like he belongs in because, of course, ultimately he's "one of us." Successful because he did it on his own, Daniel Boone swinging an axe at the nanny state, rugged American individualist exceptionalism in full motherfuckin' effect.
Political deconstruction aside, "Happyness" is an open window into American attitudes on race and class, and it's hard to believe that the filmmakers were actually as unconsciously blunt with their treatment of those attitudes as it sometimes seems. Yes, Gardener did get a Golden Ticket and wind up in the glass elevator with Willy Wonka, and you can't knock the man's intelligence, resourcefulness, or panicked desperation, but as an artistic reflection of our Victorian-era beliefs on the nature of poverty, it's strikingly on point.
The producers obviously tried to avoid making any kind of definitive ideological statement, but the images in the movie speak for themselves (or despite themselves). The movie is Hillary Clinton and Alex Jones not talking politics at a bus stop. What the fuck is the conversation about, then??
At one point, Will Smith waxes poetic about constitutional philosopher-(and slave owner)-extraordinaire Thomas Jefferson's brilliant foresight in guaranteeing the "pursuit" of happiness, not the achievement of the actual state of mind itself. Deep. But, looking back, if Jefferson had been a Calvinist, like the vast majority of early American pilgrims who got the "unwelcome" boot-in-the-ass from England, we might instead have been guaranteed the pursuit of "whatever God decides to give you."
Calvinists were the original terrified, self-flagellating fire-and-brimstone theists, and their world view, known as "supralapsarianism" (thank you Wikipedia) cast God as a kind of Santa Claus-meets-Doctor Joseph Mengele, an angry maniac who decided before you were born whether you'd be destined for salvation or damnation. Those on the "kisses" list would achieve material success and wealth, those on the "kicks" list would, well, basically get their asses kicked by life and then go to hell. Sweet.
In Northern European countries, England, and the United States, Calvinist protestantism was the backbone for the culture of expansionist capitalist investment that's brought us such important products as "the World."
In an guilt trip-ideology that would put a Jewish grandmother from Brooklyn to shame, Calvinists believed that we were all essentially predestined in one way or another to be either on God's good or bad side, and that one of the best indicators of where you stood with the big guy was how much visible material success you were able to achieve. Apparently God loves Jermaine Dupri (almost as much as the repo men do).
But the repressed, puritan streak of the philosophy also preached that any gluttonous possession of the gaudy trappings of wealth was another no-no, as was charity for the poor, which would only increase "beggary." Which brought up a problem: what to do with the chests full of gold in the basement? You had proof that God liked you more than the other kids, sure, but if he didn't want you to spend it or give it away, what did you do with it? Simple. Invest it.
While Spaniards, Italians, and other Catholics wasted their time with senseless shit like art, food, music, and family, the protestant work ethic of the Calvinists was driving industrialization by equating spirituality with progress. For the wealthy, the generation of more riches became a directive from God Himself, and the poor assholes who had to cut their fingers to shreds working in mills and factories were left believing that if He had their back they'd be in better fiscal shape.
Of course, the functional nature of industrial capitalism requires a constant pool of servile labor, and there's a very finite amount of wealth in the world, but that's obviously neither here nor there.
With the invention of the 'free market' and emphasis on competitive enterprise that was the foundation of American economics, the idea of the "American Dream" took hold, which, although less overtly religious than previous narratives, still contained many of the Calvinist principles that it traced its genesis back from. Still, at that point the inaccessibility of that dream for certain groups of people was open and assumed; black slaves and poor immigrants were not exactly given a map.
The creation of wealth eventually became a spiritual path in and of itself, and when the (nominally) secular character of America overtook the puritanical views of the early settlers, the religion-as-work philosophy lost its emphasis on God and the acquisition of fortune for fortune's sake became the dominant cultural mindstate.
Where once the back-breaking labor that sustained economic growth was in essence a form of religious self-mortification, now it was just part of the game. Only, the rules were basically the same: if your life wasn't how you wanted it to be, tough shit, that's your fault. Original sin with a gold Mercedes pendant on a truck chain.
Famous German philosopher and social commentator (yeeeeeah) Max Weber made this point about our seemingly inevitable destiny of bad coffee, irritating coworkers, and soul-crushing commutes:
"The Puritan wanted to work in calling; we are forced to do so. For when asceticism was carried out of monastic cells into everyday life, and began to dominate worldly morality, it did its part in building the tremendous cosmos of the modern economic order. This order is now bound to the technical and economic conditions of machine production which today determine the lives of all the individuals who are born into this mechanism, not only those directly concerned with economic acquisition, with irresistible force. Perhaps it will so determine them until the last ton of fossilized coal is burnt."
Translation: "projects are strategically set up/ so that in case the shit erupts/ they're easily blown up." So, don't look at me, I'm fucked too. But, hopefully somebody's paying attention, because we sure as hell aren't thinking about where this is all taking us, or if it might be smarter to consider alternative priorities.
For the meantime, to quote an aging rocker, "you're gonna have to serve somebody." The problem is, there's only so many wealthy people to serve, and the drunk-uncle open secret of our society is that a few of us are just destined to slip through the cracks. *shrug*
So while Calvinist philosophy still drips out of the lips of modern politicians in the guise of phrases like 'culture of personal responsibility,' figures like Gardener reinforce the myth of universal opportunity that most middle-class Americans don't generally have the occasion to objectively examine, let alone struggle with.
For cultural conservatives in particular, that cadre of well-funded and rigidly self-assured ideologues, Gardener's story is the ultimate straw man; eternally quotable proof that society offers meaningful opportunities for achieving 'happyness' to not just some of its citizens, but all of them.
Problem is, that belief is so full of shit that if you gave it an enema you'd have to bury it in a matchbox (to steal a phrase). There are only so many open slots, no matter how you look at it. Not that it matters, anyway, considering that the movie doesn't actually ask you to think about any of this, at least intentionally, and ultimately it's easy to imagine people on all ends of the political spectrum leaving the theater and unconsciously stepping over bums on the way to their cars, engrossed in conversation about how fuckin' cute the little kid with the afro was.
And that guy laying in the gutter mumbling to himself and wearing a trash bag as pants? Well, if he had any brains he'd be submitting internship applications at J.P. Morgan instead of drinking Ginger Flavored Brandy and sleeping on subway grates, smelling like ass and waiting for a handout.
The bottom line is that The Pursuit of Happyness manages to be social satire and subversive political commentary while simultaneously managing to somehow avoid being either. The cloudy, whistle-past-the-graveyard consciousness of America is in full effect here; everybody's happy when the credits roll, the Dream is alive and coming up triple-7s, and there's no need to notice how the movie is accidentally tongue-in-cheek about just how unrealistic it can be to expect people to achieve it.
Just to get in the door for the internship interview, Will Smith has to impress a heavily jowled Dean Whitter executive in a taxi by solving a rubix cube. A fucking rubix cube. Maybe I'm not giving the producers enough credit here, come to think about it... Maybe that's a brilliant metaphor; "so you've got a felony conviction, no immediate family, and a drug problem? Okay, get cracking on that cube ... shit, it's probably as good a shot as you've got!"
The Pursuit of Happyness is definitely not a good movie, on any level. But, that much was already obvious to you. Chances are if you're reading this you've been thinking "why does he think I give a shit, anyway, and come to think of it, it's weird that he rented that in the first place, let alone wrote a 2,000 word blog post about it."
Yes. Yes it is.
Plus, if you know me, you're probably familiar with my Nike-hoarding, $40 T-shirt empty-spirited consumerism. Who doesn't want to stack enough paper up to wake up at 11am every day and still be able to own appliances that make little fly digital noises when you use them? Getting money isn't the problem; whatever little chunk of the pie you think you have is only crumbs, anyway.
But keep in mind, the whole situation is set up in a way that makes it inevitable that some people are going to hurt, and hurt badly. Instead of looking at that problem as solvable, a solid majority block in this country holds tight to the belief that people drown in the inner city because they're fuckups, and that government funding for things like social services, mental health care, drug treatment programs, and prisoner re-entry is an undeserved luxury.
Yeah, some people are assholes and dig their own graves, that's a basic reality of dealing with a life situation intelligently, but let's at least acknowledge that there are extremely limited options for a lot of good people, and most of them aren't going to hit the lottery Trading Places-style and retire in Fiji on their 401k. So, fuck "happyness," maybe let's start with food and shelter and see where we can go from there...

Back on track, for you philistines who aren't into watching suicidally corny trashbin adult fairytales for the sole purpose of stroking your smug elitism, you could pick up a flick that might just change your life, or at least make you think twice before you order a man to kill himself.
Harakiri, the early 1960s samurai fable by chronically anti-authoritarian Japanese director Masaki Kobayashi, is shot entirely in black and white, and unlike The Pursuit of Happyness it knows exactly what it is, what it's about, and what your dumb ass is supposed to walk away thinking about after the credits roll.
In a plot that's as relevant to the United States today as it was to the shattered husk of post-imperialist Japanese society when it first dropped, Kobayashi exposes the hypocrisy and fragility of the rah-rah honor myths that authoritarian institutions shroud themselves in when the cameras are on, but still also manages to remind you (in case you forgot) that the last guy you want to fuck with is a masterless samurai with nothing to lose.
It also happened to be one of the favorite movies of my teacher, stepfather, and enigmatic intellectual hero Chogyam Trungpa Rinpoche, Tibetan Buddhist meditation master and penetratingly utilitarian connoisseur of all forms of personal expression. So take my word for it: this is worth the watts you'll burn watching it. It's the kind of film that just isn't being made these days; if you like Stanley Kubrick, Toshiro Mifune, Quentin Tarantino or any combination thereof, this is one for you.
The setting: feudal Japan. Around 1500, the Tokugawa clan took control of most of the country after winning a famous battle at Sekigahara. Any clans or houses that had allied themselves with the enemies of the Tokugawa were forcibly disbanded and the samurai under their employ were forced to become nomads, known as ronin.
No longer able to cash checks for chopping necks, and without the easily exploitable third-world conflicts that keep today's privately owned warriors out of the unemployment line, these unfortunates were forced into lives of aimless poverty and dishonor (and became the inspiration for any number of killer Japanese films).
In Harakiri, Tatsuya Nakadai stars as one of these jobless badasses, and like Gardener, he's forced to work shitty jobs to try and support his wife and son, only in what's probably a more likely outcome for people who find themselves in that position than Gardener's Gordon Gecko two-step, they get sick and die when he can't afford medical care for them (thankfully, we don't live in a ruthless medieval feudal dictatorship, and have a much more enlightened perspective on health care now).
That kind of plot twist might have been a little heavy for the soccer moms, church youth groups, and awkward dates that helped The Pursuit of Happyness gross $300 million worldwide, but Kobayashi is trying to send a slightly different message to his audience here. Sugar cookies will not be sold at the concession stand, ladies and gentlemen. Riot police are stationed at the exits.
After the death of his wife, his teenage son-in-law runs off to see the feudal lord of the nearby powerful House of Iyi, to whom he asks for permission to commit ritual suicide in hope that the lord will take pity and hire him as a retainer. Think of it like, let's say, a very creative internship application.
Unfortunately, rubix cubes had not yet made their way to medieval Japan, and the disgusted lord forces him to kill himself painfully and graphically with his bamboo sword. Application Denied, motherfucker.
Having lost his entire family, and with nothing left but his self-respect, sword, and aura of biblical righteousness, Nakadai shows up at the House of Iyi, requests an audience with the lord that emceed his son-in-law's trip off the planet, and makes it known that he intends to separate himself from his life in a similar fashion.
In a brilliant and deadpan acting job, Nakadai recounts the story of his life, and asks the lord why his son-in-law was not granted mercy when he realized what was going to happen and asked to be spared. The lord responds to Nakadai by snidely reminding him of the importance of honor and social grace; what would people say about the House of Iyi if they were to allow a masterless samurai to back out of an honorable death that he himself requested?
In response to this, Nakadai reveals the top-knots of the three most accomplished warriors of the House of Iyi, his possession of which is explained through phenomenally well-shot and choreographed flashbacks of duels between himself and the swordsmen, which in each case end with him sparing their lives and instead choosing to cut off the locks of hair on their heads that brand them as employed samurai.
Point being, apparently getting a haircut is a death sentence for a samurai, and by all rights and means they should have committed harakiri the moment they lost their top-knots. Instead, he coldly informs the lord, they are in their homes, claiming to be sick and splashing rogaine on their heads. Apparently self-serious rigid honor codes aren't the currency at the House of Iyi that they're advertised as...
Of course, in this case, the end for Nakadai doesn't involve a benefits package and card-key to the elevator, but he goes out with his dignity intact, having exposed the ruthlessness and hypocrisy of the authoritarian Iyi clan.
The Pursuit of Happyness may have had a slightly more cheerful conclusion, but in all honesty, the idea of Will Smith clutching a burning American flag as the cops riddle him with bullets on the top floor of the Morgan Stanley building in Times Square does have a certain poetic appeal to it. Someone make a note.
In the final scene, the lord orders his consigliere to cover up all evidence of both the conduct of the three disgraced Iyi samurai and the ensuing battle with Nakadai, in doing so throwing the brittle facade of honor out the window in order to maintain the power and external image of the Iyi institution.
Sounds like a good plan, just make sure they don't find any thermite in the wreckage. People are in the habit of asking questions, after all... I guess it helps that they didn't have the internet in the Land of the Rising Sun.
Most of Kobayashi's films deal with the individual's battle with the institutions that shape his life and largely control his destiny. Having been conscripted into the Japanese army during the Pacific War, an event he described as "the culmination of human evil," he was a first-hand witness to the ruthless ability of society to impose its will on the individual and the lies that are told in that process. Generally, the artificial pageantry of collective self-aggrandizement masks very basic impulses: greed and ego, to be blunt.
Harakiri was Kobayashi's allegory for individual powerlessness in the face of hierarchical social structures, in particular the big Japanese corporations that sprung up in the postwar period (the same ones that 40 years later would make headlines for becoming the first commercial businesses where people would literally work themselves to death).
Just like the belief in universal opportunity and the American work ethic makes it easier for us to stomach problems like homelessness and poverty, Japanese cultural attitudes of honorable servitude and collective destiny softened the blow of total individual submission to authority that was required by the zaibatsu.
Kobayashi believed, however, that individuals had agency in that process, and had an obligation to confront the dishonesty of social conventions that demand respect for personal ambition (or confusion) that cloaks itself in hollow ideals.
It probably wouldn't be smart to be too literalist about the whole thing and show up at the White House with a samurai sword, demanding vengeance for your fallen comrades; as much as I want to believe that might serve some communal benefit, it probably wouldn't do much more than get you badly tazered, but still, Kobayashi's point is probably even more relevant today for us than it was for 60s-era Japan:
Big buildings tend to have dark secrets, and beware those who walk their halls, trading in the currency of simple narratives; the reality of the situation is likely far more complicated (or straightforward) than it may seem, and history is always written by the survivors...