
Human Rights Watch, also known as the "other" Amnesty International, was established in the late 1970s as a mechanism to monitor social and political freedoms in the former Soviet Union, mainly those of high-profile dissidents like Andrei Sakharov who were making headlines during Ford and Carter-era detante. Helsinki Watch, as it was then known, was the brainchild of New York-based publishing executives (who were sympathetic to the position of the persecuted Russian writers) and human rights law experts, and its mandate was relatively narrow. Since then, it has responded to the needs of the ever-expanding sub genres of "human rights" by growing, growing, growing, until now it's a multi-million dollar NGO that focuses on everything from union busting at Wal-Mart to child soldiers in Sierra Leone.
While the US Program of HRW also covers immigration issues and post-9/11 security measures (colloquially understood as the place where our constitution curled up in the last few years and died), for the most part its primary concern is the day-to-day life of inmates in the ring of hell known as the US prison system, and whether what amounts to "life" in the dark places of that system meets the standards of the many international human rights treaties that the US has signed but does not observe.
While it's no longer typical for corrections officers to be chaining grown men to the floor while borderline psychopaths legally inflict corporal punishment on them, the vast majority of inmates in the prison system still experience some form of abuse or mistreatment at the hands of their "caretakers." Some of this abuse is active, like last year when a Corrections Officer in my home state of Rhode Island forced an inmate to eat his own shit, and some is passive, like the lack of quality medical care received by terminally sick prisoners, who, if not for the efforts of people like Fleet Maull, would still be dying by themselves on stained cots without even the most basic level of human comfort and decency.
Generally, western rights groups focus on what are known as "civil and political" rights at the expense of a more broad and controversial set of "economic and social" rights. For those familiar with the byzantine, politicized history of the post--WWII movement to codify international human rights law, you'll recognize the correlation between these two 'sets' of rights and two major human rights treaties that were signed in the mid-1970s: the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights (ICESCR). To sum up a long (and very dry) history, the first set of rights deals with your right to be free intellectually and the second set deals with your right to be free economically. For obvious reasons, the ICCPR was ratified and signed by the US, and the ICESCR was NOT.
As one would expect, in the maddeningly frustrating lexicon of this country, it's "American" to talk about free speech and participation in the political process, but not about health care, education, poverty, and other economic realities that make participation in that process possible and meaningful in the first place.
Many activists choose to focus on the development of holistic, "humane" prisons, and neglect the difficult questions about why we have so damn many of them in the first place. Ultimately, when we look at the fact that there are 2.3 MILLION people incarcerated in this country and almost 4 million more under some form of state supervision, it becomes clear that the social, economic, and cultural conditions which produce the steady stream of people flowing into the corrections system needs to be examined and addressed, as does the rationale behind the philosophy of punishment that inspires our national approach to social problems like drugs.
Ask yourself, why is is that the powder/crack cocaine sentencing ratio is 100/1, where possession of a drug like crack, used primarly by desperate and lost people, triggers a mandatory federal sentence that is as severe as that meted out for posession of 100 times as much powder cocaine, a drug used by a much more upwardly mobile demographic?
It's easy to cop a heroic stance on drugs when you don't have to worry about your third-year-at-prep-school-son doing a mandatory 4 year bid in a state pen for a night of snow-blowing with the good ol' boys. Nope, lock the "gang bangers" up, they're the real dangerous ones, and they're nobody's sons, right?
Ask yourself, why do we equate sound political judgment with an obligatory adoption of a "tough on crime" approach that serves no sensible purpose other than to leave convicts broken, without any meaningful tools for self-rehabilitation, and no legal vote, and releases them back into their Fallujic communities with a cynical, angry outlook on society nurtured during an incarceration marked by constant violence, degredation, and mistreatment?
Meanwhile, police brutalize the same populations that become the recruitment pool for the prison industrial complex, and the cycle becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, but when people wear "stop snitching" t-shirts, instead of pointing a deserving finger at counter-productive policing tactics, hip-hop gets blamed and labeled as subversive. Well, at least we've got Michelle Phifer saving the hood with a math textbook...
Until we address, financially and otherwise, the rot and suffering in the communities that are producing cannon fodder for this awful assembly line, prison reform as a policy goal will only be putting a band aid on much deeper issues in American society.
The bottom line is that there is no excuse for 2.3 million people to be under state lock-and-key in the most prosperous nation on earth. Even if the federal government was to wholeheartedly apply itself tomorrow to studiously monitoring the civil rights of all these incarcerated persons (as is in fact legally part of their mandate), there would not be a meaningful way of addressing the huge volume of suffering that exists within the terrible steel pit of American puritanical justice, even with the help of the numerous devoted NGOs and grass-roots organizations that work for prison reform. There are just too many inmates to keep track of, for anybody.
Politically and culturally, our philosophy is simple: build more prisons, throw impoverished people into them, and then forget they exist. And now, under current law, it's next to impossible for an inmate to bring suit in a federal court against prison administrators or guards. Before bringing a case to court against the prison, the inmate must "exhaust the grievance process," which generally includes placing responsibility for righting a wrong in the hands of the very person who committed the abuse in the first place, and even if the case is successful the lawyers who represented the prisoner are by law unable to collect substantial fees from the state for the expenses they incurred during that representation, making it next to impossible for attorneys to litigate against prisons.
Even with this under consideration, I wonder sometimes if the movement to make prisons more humane might in fact have the awful consequence of making it more culturally and emotionally acceptable for us to hold 25% of the world's incarcerated population in the brick, mortar, steel, and stone walls of the hundreds of prisons we've constructed in our national search for....what? Safety? Moral self-righteousness? Political advantage? Entertainment? Until we address the underlying desperation and poverty, both spiritual and economic, that is decimating America's communities, searching for an equitable and just prison structure is going to be a golden calf.
Step number one is taking a comprehensive look at American life and asking ourselves, "are we healthy?" It's hard to spend much time self-reflecting when we're constantly waiting to panic over the next 'threat.' Is it the Arab working at the 7-11 downtown, or the latest faceless murderer whose depressing situation Nancy Grace is publicly rolling herself in on national TV? Does anybody care anymore, or are we just so numbed that we've accepted fortress life as an inevitability? Are there alternatives?
On a very basic level, we have to look at the reasons why our prison population has grown so much over the last 20 years, and whether this growth is making our society safer or just crazier. 2.3 million. Let that number roll around in your brain for a while. That's an entire nation of people that the state legally owns.
Meanwhile, we're ordering Domino's and watching the 10-o-clock news scare us with stories of meth and murder rates, "inspiring" us into feeling justified that in places like USP Lewisburg, Angola, and ADX Florence, human beings are rotting like breathing corpses in environments that make Abu Ghraib look like the county lockup. Is this the best we expect out of ourselves, or are we that convinced that we're going to prove our moral ascendancy by throwing the book at people who've made mistakes?
At a certain point, we're going to have to wake up and consider the fact that we've routinized injustice as a fundamental underpinning of "law and order" in our society. Cliches of "first they came for my neighbor" taken into consideration (and dismissed, for now), one would be wise to contemplate what it means for all of us that our state is utterly and nakedly un-ashamed of using its most severe powers of coercion against such a large swath of our fellow citizenry. Being as used to perpetual punishment and inequality as we are is not the mark of a stable culture with an optimistic future.
/rant over.
No comments:
Post a Comment